Biology 4241 - Advanced Topics in Genetic Analysis

The Replication of DNA in Escherichia coli
By Matthew Meselson and Franklin W. Stahl
P.N.A.S. 44 (1958): 671


Introduction:

Watson and Crick:

Two months later, Watson and Crick suggested the semi-conservative model of replication.


Matthew Meselson and Franklin w. Stahl:
  Hypothesis:
  " We anticipated that a label which imparts to the DNA molecule an increased density, might permit an  analysis of this distribution by sedimentation techniques." However;
Materials and Methods:
Using Escherichia coli, Meselson and Stahl observed the distribution of the      heavy nitrogen Isotope 15N among molecules of DNA following the transfer of a uniformly 15N-labelled, exponentially growing bacteria population to a growth medium containing 14N, the naturally occurring isotope of Nitrogen.

-Escherichia Coli was grown at 360 C, in a glucose salts medium containing      ammonium chloride as the sole nitrogen source.
-Bacterial growth was measured using microscopic cell counts in conjunction with colony assays.
-Bacteria were labeled with 15N and were then abruptly changed to a medium containing 14N.
-Samples of cells were taken before the transfer and at various intervals during growth in the unlabeled medium.
-The bacterial cells were then lysed and the DNA isolated for density gradient centrifugation.
-If several different density species of DNA are present, each will form a band at the position where the density of the CsCl solution is equal to the buoyant density of that species.
-In this way, DNA labeled with heavy nitrogen may be resolved from unlabeled DNA. ( See Figure.)
-The cells' lysate was centrifuged at 140,000X g ( 44,770 rpm) for 20 hrs in CsCl solution until the DNA was isolated from other cellular components in a region of density of 1.71 g/cm3 .
-UV absorption photographs were taken throughout centrifugation with a recording microdensitometer.
-This allows the concentration and difference in buoyant density to be determined and compared.
-The buoyant density of the DNA molecules is expected to vary directly with the fraction of  15N label it contains. The degree of labeling of a species of DNA may be determined from the position of the band  relative to other bands.
-Two experiments were performed using this method. One was a sort of "trial run," while the second experiment reinforced their findings and experimental method as well.
-The first experiment was performed by running DNA samples retrieved at increments of 0.4 of the generation time (0.81hrs).
-The following experiment wasn't as precise.  See Photographs.



Recap of Experiment:
 
  • grow E. coli on medium containing N15
  • transfer bacteria to medium containing N14
  • after each generation of growth on N14 isolate DNA and run on cesium chloride (CsCl) gradient in ultracentrifuge
  • observe location of band of DNA


  • Results:

    Meselson and Stahl proved that each time the DNA reproduced, half of the old DNA stayed the same while the other half was newly built. See it for yourself!
     

    Here are some key points...

    1.    After growing the bacteria in the heavy isotope of nitrogen for a long time, both strands of DNA would be heavy. This was the heaviest layer in the centrifuge.

    2.    After the first replication in light hydrogen, each heavy DNA split and built a new half using light nitrogen. All of this DNA would have a medium weight because it had one heavy strand and one light strand. This caused one medium layer in the centrifuge.

    3.    After the second replication, each of these medium DNA molecules split. The heavy strand built another new, light weight half, producing a medium weight DNA. The light half made another new, light weight half, producing a DNA even lighter than any before. This gave the two different layers in the centrifuge.

    4.    After the third replication, there will be only one hybrid DNA produced compared to three N14-labeled strands. As a result, the lighter band will have a
    higher concentration of DNA and thus will appear more intense. The experiment continues through a fourth and final generation, and milestone generations are compared with the T=0 result.



    Testing the Watson & Crick Structure
  • AT=2 hydrogen bonds; GC=3 hydrogen bonds
  • More energy is required to disrupt the three hydrogen bonds of a GC base pair than is required to disrupt the two hydrogen bonds of an AT base pair
  • The denaturation of double stranded DNA is easily followed spectroscopically. The purine and pyrimidine bases in DNA absorb UV light maximally at a wavelength of approximately 260 nm.
  • In double-stranded DNA, however, the absorption is decreased due to base-sticking interactions. When DNA is denatured, these interactions are disrupted and an increase in absorbance is seen. This change is called the hyperchromic effect.
  • results in change in interactions between the electron systems of the bases, as they are no longer stacked

  • They wanted to see if the DNA was in fact double stranded as Watson and Crick had proposed so...

  •    They heat denatured both E. coli and salmon sperm DNA
  •    salmon sperm DNA showed density increase of 0.0014 gm. cm. -3
  •    No change in apparant molecular weight
  •    However, in heated bacterial DNA, molecular weight is reduced to   approximately half that of unheated material
  •    Heated hybrid DNA results in loss of original half and appearance of two new density species in equal amounts, each with ~ 1/2 initial m.w.
  •    Density difference = 0.015 gm. cm. -3  ~ same as N15 label
  •    Suggest dissociation into two distinct subunits
  •    Theory tested by heating N14 and N15 separately

  • These findings resulted in two new theories...
      1)    subunits of salmon sperm DNA are more tightly bound
        2)    bacterial DNA in a more complex molecule, challenging Watson & Crick
     



    Summary
  •    By means of density-gradient centrifugation, the distribution of N15 was observed among molecules of bacterial DNA following the transfer of a uniformly N15-substituted exponentially growing E. coli population to N14 medium. Here is a nice summary figure...
  •    "We find that the nitrogen of a DNA molecule is divided equally between two physiologically continuous subunits; that, following duplication, each daughter molecule receives one of these; and that the subunits are conserved through many duplications."

  • Questions? Comments? E-mail Ben and Jason anytime...



    All text material ©2000 by Ben Hammond and Jason Davidge