NEGOTIATING NEWS #28

October 30, 2000

STATUS OF NEGOTIATIONS, 12:00 NOON, OCTOBER 30, 2000

Negotiations since Wednesday October 25th have been intensive, culminating in all-night sessions over the weekend. Virtually all contract language issues have been resolved, largely in MUNFA's favor.

Wide differences remain, however, with respect to workload and financial issues.

The strike deadline of noon on October 30th has been set back 20 hours, to allow time to analyze and respond to the administration's's latest salary proposal, received on the morning of October 30th, which shows some limited movement toward MUNFA's current position.

WORKLOAD:

Six-course norms -- The administration continues to resist MUNFA's proposals to reduce norms from 6 courses to 5 in units such as Grenfell College and Education, where 6 course norms are still the case.

Remission for above-norm scholarly activity -- The administration continues to demand the removal from the Collective Agreement of the provision entitling faculty to a one course teaching remission for above-norm scholarly activity; they wish such remissions to be solely at the discretion of the Head.

Course equivalencies -- The administration continues to seek the removal from the Collective Agreement of collegial mechanisms for determining the equivalence of non-standard teaching to 3-hour lecture courses, a provision which has allowed faculty to protect time for honors and graduate student supervision.

Distance education - the administration continues to push for changes which would allow them to assign distance education as part of normal load.

Banked time - The administration continues to press for the removal of language that allows the accumulation of banked time into a semester for research activity.

FINANCIAL ISSUES:

Salary proposals

MUNFA's current position on salary is a revision of our original proposal, designed to respond to the administration's salary proposal previously circulated to all MUNFA members. It takes the following form:

September 1 1999:

April 1 2000:

September 1 2000:

April 1 2001:

  • salaries rise 1 step [at new step size] for all members

    September 1 2001:

    • salary scale increases 1%

    April 1 2002:

    • salaries rise 1 step [at new step size] for all members.

    The proposed salary changes:

    • raise salary scales by 6 steps, which should make it possible for MUN to recruit effectively
    • recognize the PhD and comparable academic qualifications while addressing the disparity in the administration proposal in compensation of PhDs and other colleagues doing the same work
    • bring salary increases forward in time, compared to the administration proposal
    • differentially benefit lower-paid members.

    MUNFA's proposal is intended to improve on the administration offer by increasing the salaries of all members sooner. Like the administration proposal it acknowledges the significance of obtaining the usual terminal qualification in one's discipline, with a smaller differential than that proposed by the administration, offset by bringing the increase forward in time.

    As of the morning of Monday October 30th, the administration has shifted very slightly from their original salary proposal, by moving their proposed 4 step increase for those with a doctorate from September 1 2001 to 31 March 2001, a minimal departure from their original position.

    The administration remains resistant to MUNFA's attempts to bring compensation further forward in time. The administration continues to refuse to move from its position that there must be a 4 step difference between those with the doctorate and those without, including Librarians and other colleagues in disciplines for which the doctorate is not the usual terminal degree.

    Other salary issues

    Protection of market differentials - We have confirmed that the administration's proposed salary increases relate explicitly to basic annual salary. In contrast in MUNFA's current position, existing market differentials would be protected.

    Caps - MUNFA's current position would raise caps 6 steps, the administration's would raise caps by 4 steps (two for senior Librarian ranks).

    Per-course compensation and pay of sessionals - MUNFA wants compensation raised by at least $750 per course; the administration current position is that per-course stipends will be $3750, an increase of only $231.

    Distance education remuneration -- The administration seeks a sliding scale that would considerably lower the total compensation for teaching distance education classes with large enrollments, even though, in contrast to the case for standard lecture courses, the work involved in such courses grows rather than shrinks with increasing enrollment.

    Other financial issues

    Retirement and early retirement - MUNFA has moved from its original early retirement proposals, on which, it was apparent, progress would be impossible. Instead, we now propose severance pay and payment for accumulated vacation on retirement or resignation. The administration refuses both.

    Pension reform - MUNFA has moved from its original proposal for pension reform, it having become apparent that negotiating this item would be impossible in the available time. Some progress may be possible in this area, on protection of pension surplus and towards assembling the information which would make reform possible in the future.

    Insured benefits - the administration continues to insist on a cap on its costs for insured benefits, a significant clawback the impact of which will increase over time.

    MUNFA Negotiating Committee:

    • Bill Schrank (Economics) - Chief Negotiator
    • John Bear (Medicine)
    • Elizabeth Browne (Library)
    • Jon Church (Medicine)
    • Malcolm Grant (Psychology)
    • Clar Matchim (Business)
    • Eric Mintz (SWGC)
    • Jim Overton (Sociology)
    • Elizabeth Yeoman (Education)
    • Chris Youé (History)
    • Marian Atkinson (MUNFA Executive Officer, non-voting member)

    All issues of Negotiating News are accessible at http://www.mun.ca/munfa/negnews.html


    Back to MUNFA Homepage